Justice for Malayshia Allford!
Statement from Give Us Back Our Children
We are mothers, grandmothers, and aunts directly impacted by the family policing system who, with our supporters, extend our deepest sympathies to Malayshia Allford’s mother and all who loved her. We are heartbroken and outraged by her murder and horrified that the foster carer charged in the murder was previously known to have caused near fatal injuries to another child. Nonetheless the callous, racist, and sexist Phila child welfare system placed Malayshia with her.
We are putting decision makers on notice: now is the time for real systemic change based on the demands and experiences of those directly impacted by the system and the organizations of which they are a part.
Philadelphia does not need more studies, committees, hearings, or another oversight body. In 2022, a City Council Special Committee on Child Separation issued recommendations based on many hours of hearings where mothers testified on what they had been forced to go through and what would have helped their children and their families. These recommendations included:
- no removal of children because of poverty
- open family court
- no removal of children because their mother is a victim of domestic violence or because of a positive drug test
- abolish mandatory reporting
- good quality legal advocacy for families
These recommendations have never been acted on, despite our monthly protest for 4 years outside of family court calling for their implementation. The city of Philadelphia must no longer hide behind a cycle of studies. Real action, real systemic change must happen. The city must do what it already knows is needed, it must make systemic change now! Those suffering as a result of family policing have been crying out, but our voices have been ignored this has led to tragedies like the murder of Malayshia and the countless suffering of other children.
Malayshia’s mother was a victim of domestic violence. Yet instead of helping her, DHS removed her daughter. Only 12% of children are removed because of abuse within the family –usually by the father or stepfather. While the majority of children are removed for “neglect” rather than abuse, poverty, disability, and domestic violence are routinely treated as neglect. We, as mothers, are our children’s first protectors. Once they are denied our protection, they are vulnerable to abuse by people and institutions who have no love for or commitment to them. Children do not belong to the state – they belong with their families, especially with their mother with whom they have a crucial bond.
As in Malayshia’s case, the Philadelphia Department of Human Services (DHS) contracts with local Community Umbrella Agencies (CUA) to manage foster care. CUAs have been sued nearly 70 times for allowing kids in their care to be burned, beaten, sexually assaulted, or killed. Nationally, one-third of foster children report emotional, physical, or sexual abuse by their foster families. Under CUA supervision, more than 14 children have been killed in foster care in Philly. Instead of taking responsibility, the child removal industry continues to protect themselves, their jobs, their money, and their power while elected officials call for more studies and commissions.
Children are traumatized and harmed when DHS takes them from their families. But poverty is not neglect. Many of these removals can be prevented. Lack of money for food, clothing, housing, utilities, childcare, transportation, home repairs, or health care must not be deemed neglect to justify family separation. They should not be a basis to investigate or remove children from their homes. Instead, money and direct services should be provided to mothers and primary caregivers to support children staying at home. Furthermore, children whose mothers are dealing with domestic violence are harmed when DHS removes them from their mothers and places them with other violent individuals, or even the very perpetrator the mother is trying to escape. Mothers who are victims of domestic abuse are all too often afraid to report it because they know if they do their children will be removed by DHS. The system makes life more dangerous for mothers and our children at every level.
Philadelphia has the highest poverty rate of any large city in the U.S. and removes children at the highest rate in the U.S.; the U.S. has the highest rate of removal in the world. These high rates continue despite the official removal rate in Philly being cut in half as a result of our efforts and the efforts of hundreds of other mothers and families. (Unfortunately, some of this reduction is actually a shell game of informal arrangements called “hidden foster care”.) When family members come forward to care for children, they are bypassed despite DHS’s stated policy to prioritize family placement, or they find themselves facing burdensome regulations and restrictions, as well as lack of financial and other support.
Black children in particular are targeted – nationally 53% of Black children will have an interaction with child welfare by the time they are 18 years old. The family policing system is rooted in chattel slavery and the forced removal of Indigenous children. And today ICE invades our communities to separate immigrant children from their families – it is unknown how many child welfare agencies cooperate with ICE.
An aunt whose nieces were removed from her care by DHS noted, “I was racially profiled and targeted because I was low-income. But I had a roof over my head, food in my fridge, a pot to piss in and a window to throw it out of. And I loved them. Years later when I reconnected with my nieces, they were in a mental health facility. Another nephew who spent his life in a facility was in prison.”
Another mom said “My kids were taken because of a false allegation by a vindictive father and the social workers kept going on about my low income. They were placed in care where they weren’t cared for. They missed school, doctors’ appointments, and given the wrong size diapers. And where’s all this money that DHS claims they give to families to help out? All I ever got was a $15 gift certificate while welfare took away my SNAP and TANF.”
The family policing system is designed to impoverish mothers and destroy family bonds, while profiting from our pain and the pain of our children. It sets us all on the road to ill health and criminalization. When children return home from foster care, they are traumatized and broken. Children in foster care suffer twice the rate of PTSD as Gulf War veterans. The foster care-to-prison pipeline is evident in states that collect the pertinent data, such as California where 70% of those involved in the criminal justice system have previously been in the foster care system.
We are acutely aware of the power of money to break or support families. A decade after welfare reform in 1996, we saw the budget to remove children had skyrocketed by 20,000%. At the same time, the welfare cash support for single mothers was frozen at an unlivable $403 per month for a mother with 2 children in Pennsylvania. It has not increased for inflation, and it imposes time limits and work requirements, ignoring the fact that raising children is work – essential, hard and skilled work. The foster care system became an extremely profitable industry, while we suffered heartache and hardship trying to keep our families together.
We also saw the reverse when during the pandemic the Child Tax Credit was extended for the first time to mothers, grandmothers and other primary caregivers who were full-time unpaid caregivers. Immigrants with ITIN numbers were included, and it was paid monthly without mandated work requirements. Nearly fifty percent of children were lifted out of poverty and child welfare interactions dropped. Guaranteed income and care income pilots for moms around the country have had similar results.
We reject efforts to “fix” the foster care system by getting more social workers, more training, more oversight, and more policing. Millions of dollars are already spent on foster families, facilities, and professionals who arrogantly claim they know what is best for our children.
The evidence is clear. The child “welfare” system in Philadelphia is a child removal industry which hurts and endangers our children’s lives and wellbeing. It cannot be fixed.
Resources now spent to remove children must instead to mothers and primary caregivers. They have earned the right to a guaranteed care income (GCI). In the US unpaid family caregivers contribute $1.5 trillion to the economy. Direct cash, a GCI, would enable children to stay in their homes as it would enable caregivers to cover basic necessities, escape abusers, and provide children with recreational activities. For example, one third of children would be home tomorrow if their mothers or families had decent housing.
The city of Philadelphia should enact legislation to establish that poverty is not neglect and children must not be removed because their mothers/caregivers are impoverished. It must get monies to mothers, not to agencies. And it must ensure that the city agencies responsible for Malayshia Allford’s murder are held to account and that policies that unjustly separate children from their families are finally halted.
Give Us Back Our Children (GUBOC) is a national multiracial network of organizations, mothers, grandmothers and supporters opposing separation of children from their mothers or other primary caregivers by the “child welfare” system. GUBOC is part of the international Support Not Separation network.
More info: +1 215-848-1120 (US) philly@allwomencount.net
